Tub vs. Shower: What Home Buyers Actually Want in 2026

TL;DR: Most home buyers in 2026 prefer walk-in showers over traditional bathtubs, especially in primary bathrooms. However, keeping at least one tub—particularly in homes with young children or multiple bathrooms—can still protect resale value. The right choice depends on your lifestyle, home layout, and local buyer demographics.

—

Key Takeaways

• Walk-in showers are the top preference among buyers in primary bathrooms, valued for convenience and modern aesthetics.
• Homes with at least one bathtub tend to retain broader resale appeal, especially in family-oriented markets.
• Working with a trusted bathroom remodeler in Columbus, OH can help you make a data-driven decision that boosts both comfort and home value.

—

The bathroom has become one of the most scrutinized rooms during a home sale. Buyers aren’t just glancing at tile colors—they’re evaluating functionality, layout, and whether the space fits their daily routine. And one question keeps coming up: tub or shower?

The answer isn’t as simple as it used to be. Preferences have shifted, demographics have changed, and what worked for buyers a decade ago may actively hurt your listing today. If you’re weighing a bathtub replacement or a shower replacement before selling—or simply want a bathroom that works better for your life—understanding what buyers actually want in 2026 matters.

Why Shower Preference Has Surged Among Modern Buyers

Walk-in showers have dominated bathroom renovation trends for several years, and that momentum hasn’t slowed. Buyers increasingly associate large, open showers with luxury, ease of cleaning, and accessibility—three things that resonate across age groups.

Younger buyers, in particular, tend to view soaking tubs as underused. If you rarely draw a bath, a large tub occupying a third of your bathroom floor plan can feel like wasted square footage. A well-designed walk-in shower with quality fixtures, on the other hand, gets used daily and signals a thoughtfully updated space.

Accessibility is another major driver. As more buyers plan for aging-in-place living, curbless shower entries and grab bars are increasingly desirable features—not afterthoughts. A shower replacement that incorporates these elements can broaden your home’s appeal well beyond any single demographic.

Does Removing a Bathtub Hurt Resale Value?

This is the question homeowners worry about most—and the answer depends heavily on context.

Removing the only bathtub in a home is generally considered a risk. Real estate professionals have long noted that homes without any tub can be harder to sell, particularly to families with young children. Bathing kids in a shower simply isn’t practical, and buyers with toddlers will notice immediately.

However, the calculation changes when your home has multiple bathrooms. Converting the primary bathroom to a shower-only setup while keeping a tub in a secondary bath is a strategy many buyers and real estate agents actually prefer. It delivers the spa-like primary bath buyers want without sacrificing the practicality families need elsewhere.

The takeaway: if you have only one bathroom, keep the tub. If you have two or more, the primary bath is fair game for a shower replacement.

What Columbus, OH Buyers Are Looking For in 2026

Local market dynamics matter as much as national trends. Columbus has seen steady population growth, with a diverse buyer pool that includes young professionals, families, and downsizing empty nesters. Each group brings different priorities to the bathroom.

Young professionals in neighborhoods like Short North or German Village tend to favor sleek, modern showers with frameless glass enclosures and minimalist fixtures. Families purchasing in Dublin or Hilliard frequently want that second-bathroom tub, especially if there are school-age children in the picture. Downsizers, meanwhile, often prioritize accessibility—making a walk-in shower with a low or zero threshold a smart long-term investment.

A knowledgeable bathroom remodeler in Columbus, OH will factor in your specific neighborhood, your home’s buyer profile, and your timeline before recommending a direction. Cookie-cutter advice rarely serves Columbus homeowners well, given how varied the city’s real estate submarkets can be.

Bathtub Replacement: When It Makes Sense to Upgrade, Not Remove

Not every bathroom decision is tub-versus-shower. Sometimes the right move is a bathtub replacement rather than an elimination.

If your current tub is outdated, stained, or damaged, replacing it with a modern soaking tub or a deep freestanding model can significantly elevate the room’s appeal. Freestanding tubs, in particular, have become a design statement—especially in larger primary bathrooms where there’s also a separate walk-in shower. Buyers in higher price brackets often expect to see both.

A fresh bathtub replacement also avoids the cost and complexity of reconfiguring plumbing, which can escalate quickly depending on your home’s existing layout. In bathrooms where the footprint works, upgrading the tub itself may deliver strong visual impact for a lower investment than a full conversion.

How to Decide: Tub, Shower, or Both?

Use these practical criteria to guide your decision:

Choose a shower replacement if:

• Your home has at least two bathrooms, and one already has a tub
• You’re targeting young professional or empty nester buyers
• Accessibility and ease of use are a priority
• The primary bath has enough space for a substantial walk-in shower

Opt for a bathtub replacement if:

• Your current tub is in poor condition but the overall layout still works
• You’re in a family-oriented neighborhood and want broad appeal
• Your bathroom has space for both a freestanding tub and a separate shower

Keep both if:

• Your primary bathroom is large enough to accommodate each
• You’re targeting a higher price point where buyers expect luxury features
• Your goal is maximum resale flexibility

Making the Right Call for Your Columbus Home

There’s no universal right answer—but there is a right answer for your home, your market, and your goals. The shift toward showers is real and continues to accelerate, but it’s not absolute. Context determines outcome.

Before committing to any renovation, consult with a bathroom remodeler in Columbus, OH who understands local buyer behavior and can evaluate your existing space honestly. The best renovation is one that reflects what Columbus buyers are actually looking for—not just what’s trending on design blogs.

Otterly Baths specializes in shower replacements and bathtub replacements across the Columbus area, helping homeowners make smart, well-informed updates that hold up when it counts. Reach out today to explore what’s possible for your bathroom.

—

Frequently Asked Questions

Does removing a bathtub hurt home value?
It can, depending on your home’s layout. Removing the only tub in a single-bathroom home is widely considered a resale risk. In homes with multiple bathrooms, converting the primary bath to a shower while keeping a tub in another bathroom typically has little to no negative impact on value—and can increase appeal among adult buyers.

What do most home buyers prefer: a tub or a shower?
According to recent buyer surveys, most buyers prioritize a large, well-designed walk-in shower in the primary bathroom. However, having at least one bathtub somewhere in the home remains important to a significant portion of buyers, particularly families with young children.

How much does a shower replacement cost in Columbus, OH?
Costs vary depending on the size of the shower, materials selected, and whether plumbing reconfiguration is required. A straightforward shower replacement in Columbus typically ranges from a few thousand dollars for a prefabricated unit to significantly more for a custom tile walk-in with frameless glass. A local estimate from a Columbus bathroom remodeler will give you the most accurate figure.

Is a freestanding bathtub worth the investment before selling?
In higher-priced homes with larger primary bathrooms, a freestanding tub can serve as a compelling design feature—especially when paired with a separate walk-in shower. In modest or mid-range homes, the return on investment is less certain. A targeted bathtub replacement with a more standard model may deliver better value relative to cost.

How do I find a reliable bathroom remodeler in Columbus, OH?
Look for a contractor with verified local reviews, a portfolio of completed bathroom projects in the Columbus area, and transparent pricing. Otterly Baths serves homeowners throughout Columbus and surrounding communities with expert shower replacement and bathtub replacement services.